Yesterday, I published a review of an eBook that a friend had brought to my attention because the author claimed to have cured her Migraines and was offering advice to others as a possible cure for theirs. To her credit, she did say, "I can’t guarantee your migraines will be cured, because everyone’s migraines are different," but the claim of her cure was made. (See 5 Steps to Solving Your Migraine Mystery - A Review.)
Because of that review, I received a message on Facebook, asking me to review another book about Migraine. In that book, the author claims to have discovered the cause of Migraine. I don't put much stock in that statement because scientists have theories, but the best of them say that the cause is still not definitively identified or fully understood.
Over the years, so many people have told me that they have the cure for Migraine disease, that they've discovered the true cause, or made other claims such as having developed miraculous treatments. I couldn't even begin to count how many people have come to me with their claims or how many other claims I've come across because other people pointed them out or I came across them myself.
So, how do we determine what claims to consider and which ones to dismiss? This is where we need to employ simple logic. Some people would say, "Show me the money!" I say, "Show me the science!" I want to see science-based evidence if someone tells me they have an effective treatment. Testimonials aren't going to convince me. Nothing works for everyone, and the placebo rate in clinical trials is often around 30%. So, show me published data from a double-blind, placebo-controlled clinical trial that shows the treatment to be more effective than placebo.
Some of the people who have come to me with their claims have a second claim — a claim that the world doesn't know about their discovery because pharmaceutical companies are conspiring to keep their discoveries hidden to protect their profits. Some have even said that doctors who specialize in the treatment of Migraine and other Headache disorders are conspiring to keep their discoveries hidden because they would have any patients if the discoveries came to light.
Again, let's employ some basic logic. Let's just say there are conspiracies to keep these discoveries hidden. In today's world of communication, technology, and social media, it wouldn't work. There are any number of journalists who would jump at such a story — and a chance at a Pulitzer for reporting such a heinous conspiracy. The world would know in pretty much no time at all.
There are many possible motivations for someone to claim they have the cure to Migraine disease, and not all of them are villainous. Some people write that they've cured their own Migraines. Science says there's no cure yet for this genetic neurological disease. BUT, trigger identification and management can be very effective for some people. When you read some of these stories, you notice that many of them talk about a lot of lifestyle changes — avoiding certain foods, sleep patterns, proper hydration, etc. These all represent avoidable Migraine triggers. Thus, some people who offer their "cure" advice to other people may have eliminated their triggers to the point of having very, very few Migraines. They may truly believe they're "cured."
In any case, using logic and looking for the science can help us sort our way through many of the claims that are being made in the Migraine community.
because a migraine is NOT "just a headache"